Follow us:

  • News & Links
  • News
  • France to recognise surrogate children

France to recognise surrogate children

France to recognise surrogate children

One of France's highest courts ruled that children born to surrogates abroad have the right to have their births and citizenship recognised by the state.

The ruling is something of a landmark for France, which has an outright ban on surrogacy, and has until now left such children living in legal limbo.

Children born to surrogates abroad could not previously obtain any legal status in the country, including a legal connection to their parents or a passport, nor could they register for any state benefits such as healthcare.

'Children shouldn't have to answer for their method of conception. They have a right to their civil status and to an identity,' commented France's justice minister Christiane Taubira, who also introduced the country's same-sex marriage legislation.

Last year, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that the refusal to transcribe a child born overseas to a French parent into the French birth registry contravenes the right of the child to establish an identity.

In the current case, the Cour de Cassation was examining the separate cases of two gay men who fathered children born to surrogates in Russia. Over the last 10 years the court had repeatedly refused to recognise surrogate children, referring to them as having been born through a fraudulent process.

However, in the latest ruling, it stated: 'Surrogate motherhood alone cannot justify the refusal to transcribe into French birth registers the foreign birth certificate of a child who has one French parent'.

While some commentators hope that the ruling could lead to greater acceptance and easier lives for people in 'new' family forms, others said that the Cour de Cassation did not go far enough, as only the biological father, in addition to the birth mother, will be allowed on French birth certificates.

The next round of battles will likely be to allow full adoption rights to the 'second' father, in the case of gay couples, or to the 'social' mother, in the case of heterosexual couples who have turned to surrogacy. In the first instance, such cases will be dealt with by civil courts in individual jurisdictions within France.

Proposed amendments to surrogacy law have attracted a vocal opposition in France who suspect that the legislation is a 'Trojan horse', aimed to usher in the legalisation of surrogacy.

Ludovine de La Rochère, president of La Manif Pour Tous, a French protest organisation which has opposed changes to family law such as gay marriage, said that with the ruling, 'The judges have acknowledged that a child can be the subject of a contract even before its conception, reducing it to a thing that can be bought or sold: it's a major social regression'.

Average Programs Costs

Location

  • Address: 17 Holosiivska St, Business Center Morion, Kiev 03039, Ukraine
    NOTEAll meetings by appointment only.
  • Phone: +380 44 545 58 24 | Kyiv time GMT +2 (UTC +2)
  • Skype: Viber: WhatsApp: Available upon request
  • Email: Info -
  • Our office is open every Monday through Friday
  • Ukraine current time:
New Hope is not a medical facility. We provide only legal services and support throughout your process. Our job is to provide you with a matching surrogate mother and /or egg donor, control her, prepare legal paperwork in compliance with the Ukrainian laws and make everything smooth. We value our reputation and our main task is to protect your interests and represent you on the territory of Ukraine.

Contact us

NOTEOnly heterosexual married couples with medical indications for surrogacy are allowed to proceed. Single men/women, same sex marriages are not allowed. IPs must be free from HIV, Hepatitis B and C, syphilis and other diseases.

  • Absence of uterus (congenital or acquired)
  • Deformation of the cavity or neck of uterus in congenital malformations or as a result of diseases, under which carrying of a pregnancy is impossible
  • Synechia of the uterus that cannot be treated
  • A (severe) physical illness under which pregnancy threatens your life or health even if the child may not be in danger
  • Unsuccessful attempts of assisted reproductive technologies (4 or more).

NOTE Your doctor should indicate one of these reasons in the medical letter so that you will be able to proceed in Ukraine (otherwise the clinic won't accept you to the program). Please, contact us for more information if you have any questions regarding this report.

Invalid Input
Note: Some sections on our website are available to the registered users only or to New Hope clients. Guidelines and Paperwork list sections are available to our clients only. The Database section is available to clients only too.

Follow us: